Wal-Mart in Newtown

I don't live or work in Newtown so I don't know the "pluse" of the community there ... but I understand the feeling that nothing has happened on a large vacant piece of city-owned city-polluted land for a long time.

That certainly needs to be cleaned up. Seems the Wal-Mart study says it would take way more than the value of the property (even if it were clean) to fix it. -- which would seem to make sense since no one has been able to come up with a better plan.

I wonder what a survey of the residents within a mile of the site would show?

I wonder what a survey of the taxpayers of the whole city would show (since we would have to kick in the extra clean-up money)?

I almost never shop at Wal-Mart I don't really like the big box concept (except maybe Home Depot) -- but I certainly don't like a big piece of a neighborhood sitting polluted (while city owned) for years.

What do you think? Tuesday (at yet another special meeting) we will find out what the City Commission thinks..

I guess I will go out on a limb and say I am 53% YES 47% NO on this issue...

Here is the "What's Up" section of the recent SHT article ...

City commissioners will meet Tuesday at 2:30 p.m. in City Commission chambers, 1565 First St., Sarasota.

They are expected to vote on whether to sell a contaminated 18-acre Newtown property to Wal-Mart for a planned Supercenter.

Deal highlights:

Wal-Mart would pay the city about $4.9 million for the property off U.S. 301 and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Way.

The retailer would then use that money to partially clean up the site, which was used for years as an unofficial town dump.

If the cleanup cost exceeds $4.9 million, which it likely will, Wal-Mart has asked the city to pay an additional $1.7 million.

Groups concerned with Wal-Mart have urged residents to pay close attention to details specifying what kind of benefits Wal-Mart would bring to the community, and whether the retailer could walk away from the deal at any time.

Comments

What's the alternative?

How could they let this happen? I think soon enough many cities will be in exactly the same situation if somebody doesn't stop the spread of pollution. My guess is that they are accepting this sad truth and have learned to live with it. But what happens whit they babies when they will grow up?

Wal-Mart

I just said I don't shop at WalMart (I am also not the primary "shopper" at my house).

I guess we are both amazon.com shoppers. I started in Aug. 1996 ...

I am willing to spend a little more if it furthers my personal goals of a more sustainable world. I think we need to be looking for opportunities to do things smarter and more efficiently using local resources where we can.

I am 100% behind cleaning up 'brownfields' and also want more economic development for the newtown area.

Thanks for visiting.

Walmart-Newtown

A good rundown of the Walmart-Newtown development. However, you have never shopped at Walmart? That's your choice if so. I shop at Walmart for items such as automotive accessories, clothes, music, videos. I also get some of the same items online at Amazon.com, or down the street from Walmart at Discount Auto. Some of it may cost more, or cost less, but I make the choice where to spend my money. That's the beauty of the system. As stated recently online in Townhall.com, "No one is forced to shop or work at Walmart", but a heck of a lot of people do.

Am I biased? Maybe. I work hand in glove with Walmart and other private companies and individuals to cleanup contaminated sites. Walmart and others step forward and take on the responsibility and risk for assessment and cleanup activities. The reality is Walmart is a standard bearer in cleanup of sites for use as the primary store and outlying parcels as restaurants, etc. Sam Walton's company has cleaned up numerous sites and put them back into use and on the tax rolls. I view this as a much better alternative than leaving contaminated property fallow to continue impacting our groundwater.

It's easy to fault any large institution such as Walmart as being a root cause or a furtherance of problems within a community. It's a lot harder to admit that this opportunity may represent a foundation upon which a community may grow anew from.

I look forward to being a part of positive progress within our city. I hope you'll join me.

Regards,

John Sego, P.G.

City Commission Approved it

late last night. We will see in a few years if it was a good deal for Newtown.